
Top Nifty Commodities Stocks Compared: Coal India vs Vedanta vs Hindalco vs Tata Steel vs UltraTech Cement on Price, Valuation, Q2 FY27 Results and Risks
Previous close: Coal India Rs 391.55, Vedanta Rs 255.03, Hindalco Rs 927.75, Tata Steel Rs 181.50, UltraTech Cement Rs 12,290.00.
Updated: 18 Nov 2026 • 10:20 am
Posted by:

Quick Answer
This nifty commodities stocks compared snapshot checks five names on price, valuation and Q2 FY27 results: Coal India, Vedanta, Hindalco, Tata Steel and UltraTech Cement. UltraTech Cement is the largest by market capitalisation at Rs 3,61,225 crore. Vedanta reports the highest return on equity at 77.48%. Nifty Commodities names follow different raw material cycles, so read each multiple next to margins and returns.
Nifty commodities stocks compared here means Coal India, Vedanta, Hindalco, Tata Steel and UltraTech Cement on one page, checked on previous close, market value, valuation and the latest quarterly numbers. The group covers a coal miner, a diversified metals miner, an aluminium and copper maker, a steel maker and a cement maker, so each name follows its own commodity, which is exactly why a side-by-side look helps.
All five companies have filed their September 2026 quarter, so every result below is Q2 FY27. Nifty Commodities stocks follow commodity prices, global demand and domestic construction activity, so a glance at the Nifty Metal page and the Sensex page before you read the tables gives useful backdrop.
Click Here – Get Free Investment Predictions
Nifty Commodities Stocks Compared: Five Names on the List
The nifty commodities stocks compared here are Coal India, Vedanta, Hindalco, Tata Steel and UltraTech Cement. UltraTech Cement is the largest by market capitalisation at Rs 3,61,225 crore. Previous closes run from Rs 181.50 for Tata Steel to Rs 12,290.00 for UltraTech Cement, which is why a side-by-side look at value rather than price is more useful. This nifty commodities stocks compared list is the base for every table that follows.
| Stock | Previous close (Rs) | Market cap (Rs crore) |
|---|---|---|
| Coal India | 391.55 | 2,45,277 |
| Vedanta | 255.03 | 99,011 |
| Hindalco | 927.75 | 2,07,868 |
| Tata Steel | 181.50 | 2,33,692 |
| UltraTech Cement | 12,290.00 | 3,61,225 |
A quick look at the business behind each ticker puts the numbers in context. Coal India mines coal for power and industry, while Vedanta mines and makes zinc, aluminium, oil and gas and other metals. Hindalco makes aluminium and copper products, and Tata Steel makes steel in India and abroad. To compare nifty commodities stocks properly, line up price to earnings, return on equity and dividend yield before forming a view.
Rounding out the group, UltraTech Cement makes cement. A fair nifty commodities stock comparison looks at what each company actually earns from, not only at the share price. A miner and a building materials maker belong in separate mental boxes whenever you compare nifty commodities stocks fairly.
Nifty Commodities Stocks Valuation: Multiples, Returns and Payouts
Vedanta trades at the lowest price to earnings ratio in this group at 3.17. It also reports the highest return on equity at 77.48%. Hindalco has the lowest price to book value at 1.30. These nifty commodities stocks valuation readings come from the previous close and the latest reported financials. That is the idea behind this nifty commodities stocks compared table: price to earnings and return on equity sit side by side so a high or low reading stands out at once.
| Stock | Price to earnings | Price to book | ROE (%) | Dividend yield (%) | Debt to equity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coal India | 7.33 | 1.92 | 26.17 | 6.66 | 0.12 |
| Vedanta | 3.17 | 7.76 | 77.48 | 13.43 | 2.44 |
| Hindalco | 10.83 | 1.30 | 14.58 | 0.53 | 0.71 |
| Tata Steel | 19.83 | 2.29 | 11.18 | 2.14 | 0.99 |
| UltraTech Cement | 40.89 | 4.91 | 11.96 | 1.96 | 0.40 |
Price to earnings, return on equity, debt to equity and dividend yield give the clearest picture of valuation, returns and balance sheet room across the five names. Earnings per share and book value per share are the building blocks behind price to earnings and price to book, so a glance at both in each filing is time well spent. A simple nifty commodities stock comparison like this one is only as useful as the context behind it, which is why dividend yield is worth checking as well.
In this group, price to earnings runs from 3.17 for Vedanta to 40.89 for UltraTech Cement. Vedanta offers the highest dividend yield at 13.43%. Industry price to earnings readings differ by sub-sector: Coal India at 9.26; Vedanta and Hindalco at 10.11; Tata Steel at 21.37; UltraTech Cement at 36.71. The industry price to earnings is a handy anchor: a stock above it is priced for faster growth, and one below it is priced for steadier earnings. A well-built nifty commodities stock comparison also notes that commodity prices can move margins between quarters. Run the same nifty commodities stock comparison on your own watchlist and the pattern in these numbers will be easier to spot.
Nifty Commodities Stocks Q2 FY27 Results: Revenue and Profit Check
All of the five nifty commodities stocks compared have filed Q2 FY27 numbers. Vedanta posted the fastest revenue growth at 58.0% year on year. Vedanta showed the sharpest rise in net profit at 78.3%. Read revenue first and quarterly profit second, since the two together show how much of the growth reaches shareholders. Treat the Q2 FY27 numbers in this nifty commodities stocks compared review as a snapshot of one quarter, not a verdict on any commodity company.
| Stock | Q2 FY27 revenue (Rs crore) | Q2 FY26 revenue (Rs crore) | Q2 FY27 net profit (Rs crore) | Q2 FY26 net profit (Rs crore) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coal India | 46,833 | 38,694 | 6,547 | 4,167 |
| Vedanta | 26,866 | 17,000 | 6,202 | 3,479 |
| Hindalco | 92,651 | 66,771 | 7,533 | 4,741 |
| Tata Steel | 65,685 | 59,053 | 3,700 | 3,183 |
| UltraTech Cement | 23,406 | 19,781 | 1,501 | 1,238 |
Coal India Results Snapshot
Coal India reported Q2 FY27 revenue of Rs 46,833 crore, compared with Rs 38,694 crore a year earlier, a rise of 21.0%. Net profit rose 57.1% to Rs 6,547 crore from Rs 4,167 crore. Operating margin expanded to 25.9% from 24.5% a year ago. Earnings per share for the quarter rose to Rs 10.57 from Rs 7.07.
Vedanta Results Snapshot
In the September 2026 quarter, Vedanta booked revenue of Rs 26,866 crore against Rs 17,000 crore in the same quarter last year, a rise of 58.0%. Net profit rose 78.3% to Rs 6,202 crore from Rs 3,479 crore. Operating margin expanded to 40.4% from 37.1% a year ago. Earnings per share for the quarter rose to Rs 9.30 from Rs 4.56.
Hindalco Results Snapshot
Hindalco's Q2 FY27 top line stood at Rs 92,651 crore, versus Rs 66,771 crore in Q2 FY26, a rise of 38.8%. Net profit rose 58.9% to Rs 7,533 crore from Rs 4,741 crore. Operating margin expanded to 15.3% from 14.4% a year ago. Earnings per share for the quarter rose to Rs 33.85 from Rs 21.32.
Tata Steel Results Snapshot
Tata Steel reported Q2 FY27 revenue of Rs 65,685 crore, compared with Rs 59,053 crore a year earlier, a rise of 11.2%. Net profit rose 16.2% to Rs 3,700 crore from Rs 3,183 crore. Operating margin expanded to 17.3% from 15.3% a year ago. Earnings per share for the quarter rose to Rs 2.94 from Rs 2.49.
UltraTech Cement Results Snapshot
In the September 2026 quarter, UltraTech Cement booked revenue of Rs 23,406 crore against Rs 19,781 crore in the same quarter last year, a rise of 18.3%. Net profit rose 21.3% to Rs 1,501 crore from Rs 1,238 crore. Net profit margin improved to 6.4% from 6.3%. Earnings per share for the quarter rose to Rs 50.75 from Rs 41.84.
Commodity prices, volumes and costs shape earnings, so each name needs a look at its own results, so profit can look different from revenue in a single quarter. That is why a nifty commodities stock comparison works best when revenue and profit are read together across two or three quarters. Used this way, a nifty commodities stocks compared review becomes a map of the sector rather than a price list. When you compare nifty commodities stocks after each result season, track how dividend yield changes from one quarter to the next.
Nifty Commodities Stocks Compared Two at a Time: Three Pairings
Readers rarely want a five-way table and nothing else, so here are three head-to-head reads drawn from the same data. Use them as a quick way to compare nifty commodities stocks two at a time.
Hindalco vs Vedanta
Hindalco and Vedanta both make aluminium and other metals. Hindalco is about 2.1 times the size of Vedanta by market capitalisation, at Rs 2,07,868 crore against Rs 99,011 crore. On price to earnings, Vedanta carries the lower multiple at 3.17 against 10.83 for Hindalco. Vedanta reports the higher return on equity, at 77.48% against 14.58% for Hindalco. Two metal makers with different mixes, so read margins next to valuation.
Tata Steel vs UltraTech Cement
Tata Steel and UltraTech both sell into construction demand. On price to earnings, Tata Steel carries the lower multiple at 19.83 against 40.89 for UltraTech Cement. UltraTech Cement reports the higher return on equity, at 11.96% against 11.18% for Tata Steel. For dividend income, Tata Steel offers 2.14% against 1.96% at UltraTech Cement. Two building material sellers with different products, so compare returns first.
Coal India vs Vedanta
Coal India mines coal, while Vedanta mines several metals. Vedanta reports the higher return on equity, at 77.48% against 26.17% for Coal India. For dividend income, Vedanta offers 13.43% against 6.66% at Coal India. In Q2 FY27, Vedanta grew revenue faster, at 58.0% year on year against 21.0% for Coal India. Two miners with different commodities, so read payouts together.
Best Nifty Commodities Stocks for Each Type of Investor
Which of the best nifty commodities stocks is right for you depends on your priorities, so the table below lists the leader on each measure instead of crowning one name. Any nifty commodities stocks compared table can mislead if you stop at one row, because each commodity company leads on a different measure.
| If you care most about | Start your research with | The number |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest price to earnings | Vedanta | 3.17 |
| Highest return on equity | Vedanta | 77.48% |
| Highest dividend yield | Vedanta | 13.43% |
| Lowest price to book value | Hindalco | 1.30 |
| Largest by market capitalisation | UltraTech Cement | Rs 3,61,225 crore |
| Fastest Q2 FY27 revenue growth | Vedanta | 58.0% |
| Sharpest Q2 FY27 net profit rise | Vedanta | 78.3% |
No single name tops every row, which is exactly why a nifty commodities stock comparison helps. Multiples, margins and returns point to different companies, so decide what matters most to you before you rank the numbers.
What Is Driving Nifty Commodities Stocks Right Now?
Coal, metals and cement sit at the centre of the Nifty Commodities theme, so raw material cycles reach all five names. Knowing what moves commodity prices and construction demand helps you compare nifty commodities stocks with the right questions in mind.
Commodity prices, volumes and demand decide earnings, so each name reacts to its own market. A good nifty commodities stocks compared routine therefore tracks commodity prices, volumes and quarterly results.
Risks to Weigh When You Compare Nifty Commodities Stocks
Nifty Commodities stocks depend on demand, input costs, policy and the wider market mood. Valuations differ by company, so read each filing for order, volume and margin commentary before you compare them. Every nifty commodities stock comparison has blind spots, and for this group the biggest is commodity prices and construction demand.
Because commodity prices, volumes and quarterly results drive these businesses, the most useful habit is to read the management commentary that comes with every result and note what is expected for the next quarter. Read together, the risk notes and the tables make this nifty commodities stocks compared guide a balanced starting point.
How to Compare Nifty Commodities Stocks and Build a Shortlist
Start by deciding which commodity you want exposure to, because each reads the market differently. Readers who follow commodity prices, volumes and quarterly results find the group easier to track. Done step by step, this nifty commodities stocks compared routine becomes repeatable rather than a one-off exercise.
Then check valuation and returns, because the five names rarely trade on the same multiple. A coal miner next to a cement maker shows how the business behind each price changes the numbers. Keep the shortlist of best nifty commodities stocks short enough that you can actually follow each company's quarterly results. When you compare nifty commodities stocks again after new results, update only the rows that changed instead of starting over.
The Univest stock screener lets you filter nifty commodities stocks by market capitalisation, return on equity and price to earnings, and the app keeps live prices a tap away through the trading day. Come back to this nifty commodities stocks compared page after the next set of results to see which numbers have moved.
Check the Univest Screener for live nifty commodities stock data
Download the Univest iOS App or Univest Android App to track these nifty commodities stocks live.
Conclusion: Nifty Commodities Stocks Compared at a Glance
This nifty commodities stocks compared review on price, valuation and Q2 FY27 results shows that no single name wins every measure. UltraTech Cement leads on size and Vedanta leads on return on equity, while the others bring their own strengths. Treat the nifty commodities stocks Q2 FY27 results and nifty commodities stocks valuation tables as a research starting point, then check the filings and speak to a SEBI-registered advisor before you invest. If you plan to compare nifty commodities stocks again next quarter, the same checklist of price to earnings, return on equity and dividend yield will work.
Disclaimer: Data and figures in this article are sourced from publicly available information. These may or may not be accurate. Please verify all data with the official NSE (nseindia.com) and BSE (bseindia.com) websites before making any investment decision. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice by Univest (SEBI RA INH000013776).
Frequently Asked Questions on Nifty Commodities Stocks Compared
Which are the top nifty commodities stocks compared in this article?
Ans. The nifty commodities stocks compared in this article are Coal India, Vedanta, Hindalco, Tata Steel and UltraTech Cement. They are checked on previous close, market capitalisation, price to earnings, price to book, return on equity and the latest quarterly results, so the group can be read in one sitting before you go deeper into any single company.
Which nifty commodities stock has the highest market capitalisation?
Ans. Among the five names, UltraTech Cement has the highest market capitalisation at Rs 3,61,225 crore. Coal India follows at Rs 2,45,277 crore. Market value changes with every price move, which means the ranking can shuffle, so look at the latest figure on the exchange.
Which of these nifty commodities stocks has the lowest price to earnings ratio?
Ans. On nifty commodities stocks valuation, Vedanta has the lowest price to earnings ratio among these nifty commodities stocks at 3.17, based on the latest reported earnings. UltraTech Cement sits at the other end at 40.89. Treat the lowest multiple as a place to start asking questions, because growth and business quality explain why investors pay more or less.
Which nifty commodities stock has the highest return on equity?
Ans. Vedanta reports the highest return on equity in this group at 77.48%. In plain terms, return on equity tells you how hard shareholder funds are working. Read it across a few years and alongside debt, since a high ratio built on borrowing carries more risk.
How did nifty commodities stocks perform in Q2 FY27 results?
Ans. All of the five names have filed Q2 FY27 numbers in our data. Vedanta recorded the fastest revenue growth at 58.0% year on year. Vedanta showed the sharpest net profit rise at 78.3%. For nifty commodities stocks Q2 FY27 results, each filing on the exchange website carries the full detail behind these figures.
What are the main risks when you compare nifty commodities stocks?
Ans. Nifty Commodities stocks depend on demand, input costs, policy and the wider market mood. Valuations differ by company, so read each filing for order, volume and margin commentary before you compare them. Keep an eye on commodity prices, volumes and quarterly results.
Which metrics matter most when you compare Nifty Commodities stocks?
Ans. Price to earnings, return on equity, dividend yield and operating margin matter most here. Compare each multiple with the company's own commodity cycle. Read each filing for price and volume commentary.
Which is the best nifty commodities stock to buy among these five?
Ans. The best Nifty Commodities stock depends on which commodity you want exposure to, because the five names differ on all of these. On the numbers in this article, UltraTech Cement has the largest market capitalisation; Vedanta has the lowest price to earnings, the highest return on equity and the highest dividend yield. There is no clear winner across every measure, and nothing here is a recommendation. Let the tables narrow your list, confirm the numbers in the filings, and take advice from a SEBI-registered advisor before acting.
Recent Articles

Top 3 Aerospace and Defence Stocks to Watch in 2027: HAL, BEL and Solar Industries
18 November 2026

3 Telecom IT Services Provider, Pistons Gaskets and Cooling Parts Maker and Medicines Exporter Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Tech Mahindra, Banco Products (India) and Sun Pharma
17 November 2026

3 Airline Fare Software Provider, Visa Processing Firm and House Wires Producer Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Accelya Solutions India, BLS International Services and RR Kabel
17 November 2026

3 Naval Shipbuilder, Diagnostics Centres Chain and Basmati Rice Company Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders, Vijaya Diagnostic Centre and LT Foods
17 November 2026
Note: This blog is for information purpose only. Investments and trading are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
Reviews
Recent Posts
Top 3 Aerospace and Defence Stocks to Watch in 2027: HAL, BEL and Solar Industries
3 Telecom IT Services Provider, Pistons Gaskets and Cooling Parts Maker and Medicines Exporter Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Tech Mahindra, Banco Products (India) and Sun Pharma
3 Airline Fare Software Provider, Visa Processing Firm and House Wires Producer Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Accelya Solutions India, BLS International Services and RR Kabel
3 Naval Shipbuilder, Diagnostics Centres Chain and Basmati Rice Company Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders, Vijaya Diagnostic Centre and LT Foods
3 Pathology Labs Network, Digital Engineering Firm and Stainless Pipes Maker Stocks With a Strong Future Roadmap: Thyrocare Technologies, Zensar Technologies and Ratnamani Metals and Tubes

Uniresearch Global Pvt Ltd
Research Analyst
SEBI Registration Number — INH000013776
Uniresearch is a subsidiary of Univest Communication Technologies Private Limited
Company Address: Registered Address: Ground Floor, Unitech Commercial Tower 2, Block B, Greenwood City, Unit 1-3, Sector 45, Gurugram, Haryana 122003
Write to us : support@univest.in, compliance@univest.in
Verify on SEBI registry →RESEARCH ANALYST
Get SEBI Registered
advice on the stocks
trending today.
Get 3 FREE Trade Ideas
for Startups Accelerator 2024
Trusted by 1Cr Indians
Awarded No.1 by Economic Times





