ad

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel 2027: JSW's Quarterly Profit Tripled. Is Europe the Real Difference for Tata Steel?

17 Nov 2026 • 9:40 am

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel 2027: JSW's Quarterly Profit Tripled. Is Europe the Real Difference for Tata Steel?
Tata Steel vs JSW Steel at a glance Tata Steel JSW Steel
Share price (16 Nov 2026) Rs 182.26 Rs 1,334.60
Market cap Rs 2,26,888 crore Rs 3,25,979 crore
P/E ratio 19.25 10.28
Q2 FY27 net profit Rs 3,700 crore Rs 5,359 crore

Quick Answer

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel shows two different profit recoveries in the same industry. JSW Steel's consolidated net profit rose 225.6% to Rs 5,359 crore in Q2 FY27, while Tata Steel's rose 16.2% to Rs 3,700 crore. JSW Steel trades within 2.6% of its 52-week high, while Tata Steel is 18.8% below its high and pays the higher dividend yield of 2.20%. Tata Steel carries more debt, largely linked to its European operations.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel in 2027 comes down to where each company makes its steel: the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel share price trend shows that JSW Steel, an almost purely India-based producer, is recovering faster than Tata Steel, which still runs large plants in Europe. JSW Steel's September-quarter profit tripled, while Tata Steel's grew 16.2%.

Both stocks are heavyweights in the Nifty Metal index and part of the Nifty 50. JSW Steel is now the larger company by market value at about Rs 3.26 lakh crore, ahead of Tata Steel at about Rs 2.27 lakh crore. This Tata Steel vs JSW Steel comparison covers how each company earns money, the latest Q2 FY27 results, debt, valuation and risk.

Click Here – Get Free Investment Predictions

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel: Company Overview

What Tata Steel Does

Tata Steel is one of the oldest and largest steel producers in India, part of the Tata group. Its Indian plants at Jamshedpur and Kalinganagar make flat and long products for automotive, construction, engineering and consumer goods markets.

Tata Steel also owns steelmaking operations in the Netherlands and the United Kingdom. The UK business is moving from blast furnaces to electric arc furnace steelmaking, a transition that has weighed on group profits.

What JSW Steel Does

JSW Steel is the flagship of the JSW group and one of India's largest steelmakers by capacity. Its integrated plants are concentrated in Karnataka, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Odisha, with smaller operations overseas.

JSW Steel sells hot-rolled, cold-rolled, coated and value-added products, with a large share going to infrastructure, automotive and appliance makers. Its growth has come through new capacity and acquisitions of stressed assets.

How Tata Steel and JSW Steel Make Money

Both companies earn a spread between the selling price of steel and the cost of iron ore, coking coal and energy. When steel prices rise faster than raw material costs, margins widen; when coal prices jump or imports flood the market, margins shrink.

The difference is geography. JSW Steel earns almost all its profit from India, where demand from roads, railways and housing has stayed firm. Tata Steel's Indian unit is highly profitable, but its European operations face high energy costs and weaker demand, which pulls down consolidated earnings.

Captive raw materials matter too. Tata Steel has a long history of owning iron ore mines in India, which lowers costs for its domestic plants. JSW Steel has been adding captive mines to reduce its dependence on purchased ore. These structural points will still shape the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel contest when the current cycle ends.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel Share Price, Valuation and Debt Compared

Market data is as of 16 November 2026. Ratios use trailing twelve-month figures.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel metric Tata Steel JSW Steel
Share price (CMP) Rs 182.26 Rs 1,334.60
52-week high Rs 224.40 Rs 1,370.00
52-week low Rs 160.06 Rs 1,073.20
Distance from 52-week high -18.8% -2.6%
Market capitalisation Rs 2,26,888 crore Rs 3,25,979 crore
P/E ratio (TTM) 19.25 10.28
Industry P/E 21.30 21.30
P/B ratio 2.22 2.88
Return on equity (ROE) 11.18% 11.86%
Debt to equity 0.99 0.62
Dividend yield 2.20% 0.66%
FY26 revenue Rs 2,33,542 crore Rs 1,86,718 crore
FY26 net profit Rs 10,886 crore Rs 25,508 crore

JSW Steel's P/E ratio of 10.28 looks low next to Tata Steel's 19.25, but it needs care. JSW Steel reported net profit of Rs 19,243 crore in the March 2026 quarter alone, far above its usual run rate, so trailing earnings are inflated and the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel P/E gap overstates JSW Steel's valuation discount.

On balance sheets, Tata Steel's debt to equity of 0.99 is higher than JSW Steel's 0.62. Tata Steel offers the higher dividend yield at 2.20% against 0.66%. On price, JSW Steel is near its 52-week high of Rs 1,370, while Tata Steel trades 18.8% below its high of Rs 224.40.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel Q2 FY27 Results Compared

Figures are consolidated and include overseas operations.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel Q2 FY27 (Sep 2026 quarter) Tata Steel JSW Steel
Revenue Q2 FY27 Rs 65,685 crore Rs 54,927 crore
Revenue Q2 FY26 Rs 59,053 crore Rs 45,436 crore
Revenue change YoY +11.2% +20.9%
Net profit Q2 FY27 Rs 3,700 crore Rs 5,359 crore
Net profit Q2 FY26 Rs 3,183 crore Rs 1,646 crore
Net profit change YoY +16.2% +225.6%
Net profit Q1 FY27 Rs 2,385 crore Rs 4,696 crore

JSW Steel led growth in the Q2 FY27 results. Revenue rose 20.9% to Rs 54,927 crore and net profit jumped 225.6% to Rs 5,359 crore, building on Rs 4,696 crore in the June quarter.

Tata Steel grew revenue 11.2% to Rs 65,685 crore, so it remains the larger company by sales. Net profit rose 16.2% to Rs 3,700 crore and improved sharply from Rs 2,385 crore in the June quarter, a sign that margins are recovering.

The Tata Steel vs JSW Steel quarter tells a clear story: JSW Steel converts more of each rupee of sales into profit right now, while Tata Steel's recovery is slower but visible quarter on quarter.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel Profit Recovery: What Drives 2027

Tata Steel: India strength and a European reset

Tata Steel's profit recovery depends on two things. In India, higher volumes from expanded capacity at Kalinganagar support earnings. In Europe, the shift to electric arc furnaces in the UK is meant to lower costs and emissions once complete, which could reduce the drag that has held back consolidated profit.

FY26 net profit of Rs 10,886 crore was already more than three times FY25's Rs 3,174 crore, so the recovery has started. The question for 2027 is whether it can speed up.

JSW Steel: capacity growth in India

JSW Steel's growth comes from adding capacity at its Indian plants and selling more value-added steel. Strong domestic infrastructure spending is the main demand driver.

The risk is that much of the good news is already in the price, with the stock near its 52-week high. The Tata Steel vs JSW Steel recovery race will depend on steel prices and import competition through 2027.

Compare Tata Steel and JSW Steel on the Univest Screener

Key Risks in Tata Steel vs JSW Steel

Risks for Tata Steel

In the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel risk list, Tata Steel's biggest variable is Europe. Delays or cost overruns in the UK transition, weak European demand or high energy prices can wipe out Indian profits. Debt of 0.99 times equity also limits flexibility if steel prices fall.

Risks for JSW Steel

JSW Steel is exposed to low-priced imports and coking coal price spikes, since it buys much of its coal from overseas. Its trailing P/E is flattered by an unusually large March 2026 quarter, so earnings could look weaker once that drops out of the twelve-month figure.

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel Shareholding Pattern

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel shareholding (Sep '26, change vs Sep '25) Tata Steel JSW Steel
Promoters 32.95% (-0.24 pts) 44.30% (-1.02 pts)
Foreign institutions (FII) 18.19% (+0.41 pts) 26.23% (+0.68 pts)
Domestic institutions (DII) 27.52% (+0.43 pts) 11.34% (+0.47 pts)
Public and others 21.34% (-0.60 pts) 18.14% (-0.12 pts)

Tata Steel promoters hold 32.95%, with domestic institutions at 27.52% and FIIs at 18.19%, both slightly higher than a year earlier. JSW Steel promoters hold 44.30%, down about one percentage point, while FIIs own 26.23%.

In Tata Steel vs JSW Steel, JSW Steel has the larger foreign institutional base, while Tata Steel leans more on domestic funds.

Download the Univest iOS App or Univest Android App to track Tata Steel and JSW Steel live and follow metal sector research.

Which Investor Does Each Steel Stock Suit?

Tata Steel suits turnaround and income investors

Within Tata Steel vs JSW Steel, Tata Steel fits investors who want a recovery story with a 2.20% dividend yield and who accept the risk of the European business. It suits those who believe European losses will narrow over the next two years.

JSW Steel suits India-growth investors

JSW Steel fits investors who want direct exposure to Indian steel demand and capacity growth, and who are comfortable buying a stock near its 52-week high. It suits people focused on volume growth more than dividends.

Final View on Tata Steel vs JSW Steel

Tata Steel vs JSW Steel is a comparison between an India-focused steelmaker in full recovery and a global steelmaker still repairing its European arm. JSW Steel grew Q2 FY27 profit 225.6% and trades near its high, while Tata Steel grew profit 16.2%, carries more debt and pays a higher dividend.

The Tata Steel vs JSW Steel decision depends on whether an investor prefers momentum today or a potential catch-up if Tata Steel's Europe reset works. Steel prices, coal costs and quarterly profit trends will decide how the gap moves in 2027.

Disclaimer: Data and figures in this article are drawn from publicly available information and company disclosures, and they may change after publication. Please verify all data independently before making any investment decision. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice by Univest (SEBI RA INH000013776).

FAQs on Tata Steel vs JSW Steel

Which steel company grew profit faster in Q2 FY27?

Ans. JSW Steel grew profit faster. Its consolidated net profit rose 225.6% to Rs 5,359 crore, while Tata Steel's rose 16.2% to Rs 3,700 crore. Tata Steel still had the higher revenue at Rs 65,685 crore against Rs 54,927 crore for JSW Steel.

Why does JSW Steel have a lower P/E than Tata Steel?

Ans. JSW Steel's trailing P/E of 10.28 is low because its net profit in the March 2026 quarter was an unusually high Rs 19,243 crore. That quarter inflates trailing earnings and pulls the P/E down. Tata Steel trades at a P/E of 19.25, so the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel valuation gap is smaller than it first appears.

Which company has more debt, Tata Steel or JSW Steel?

Ans. Tata Steel has more debt relative to equity, with a debt to equity ratio of 0.99 compared with 0.62 for JSW Steel. Much of Tata Steel's borrowing is linked to its European operations. Higher debt makes earnings more sensitive to steel price swings.

Which pays a higher dividend yield, Tata Steel or JSW Steel?

Ans. Tata Steel pays the higher dividend yield at 2.20%, compared with 0.66% for JSW Steel. Tata Steel paid Rs 4 per share for FY26. Investors focused on income may give this more weight when comparing the two.

How does Europe affect Tata Steel's profit?

Ans. Tata Steel owns plants in the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, where energy costs are high and demand has been weak. These operations have pulled down consolidated profit even when the Indian business performs well. The UK move to electric arc furnace steelmaking is meant to reduce costs once it is complete.

What is the Tata Steel vs JSW Steel share price position against the 52-week range?

Ans. Tata Steel closed at Rs 182.26 on 16 November 2026, 18.8% below its 52-week high of Rs 224.40. JSW Steel closed at Rs 1,334.60, only 2.6% below its high of Rs 1,370. JSW Steel has held up more strongly over the year.

What should investors watch in Tata Steel vs JSW Steel in 2027?

Ans. Investors should watch domestic steel prices, coking coal costs, import trends and quarterly profit for both companies. For Tata Steel, progress on the European restructuring is the key signal. For JSW Steel, capacity additions and margins on value-added steel will matter most.

Recent Articles

Note: This blog is for information purpose only. Investments and trading are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.

Reviews

user-review-1
user-review-2
user-review-3
user-review-4
user-review-5

RESEARCH ANALYST

Get SEBI Registered
advice on the stocks
trending today.

Get 3 FREE Trade Ideas

+91
for Startups Accelerator 2024

for Startups Accelerator 2024

Trusted by 1Cr Indians

Trusted by 1Cr Indians

Awarded No.1 by Economic Times

Awarded No.1 by Economic Times

GET THE APP

Join 1Cr users today.

SEBI Registered Analyst-backed Picks. Free Demat. One App

  • Free Demat account in under 5 minutes
  • Live market data — Nifty, Sensex, sector insights
  • SEBI Registered analyst-backed stock picks
Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Stocks:
All|a|b|c|d|e|f|g|h|i|j|k|l|m|n|o|p|q|r|s|t|u|v|w|x|y|z

Copyright 2026 Univest. All rights reserved.
Designed with ❤️ in India

arrow down