Coal India vs NMDC vs MOIL: Dividend Yield, Valuation, Margins and Ownership Compared at Rs 393, Rs 68 and Rs 214
- November 19, 2026
- Posted by: Kunal Singla
- Category: News
Coal India Rs 393.10 (+1.31%), NMDC Rs 68.01 (-0.34%), MOIL Rs 214 (+1.33%) at 3:08 PM IST. P/E 7.2, 8.0, 14.8 (our arithmetic). Yields 6.8%, 5.1%, 2.5%. NSE data.
Quick Answer
At 3:08 PM IST on 19 November, Coal India traded at Rs 393.10, NMDC at Rs 68.01 and MOIL at Rs 214.00 on NSE. Coal India has the lowest P/E at about 7.2 and the highest dividend yield at 6.82%, NMDC sits at about 8.0 times earnings with a 5.12% yield, and MOIL trades near 14.8 times with a 2.52% yield (our arithmetic on trailing earnings). Coal India and NMDC both earn a return on equity above 20%, while MOIL’s is 10.42% but it carries no debt. The numbers describe three different businesses, coal, iron ore and manganese, so a lower multiple is not a ranking of outlook, and Univest makes no pick.
Coal India vs NMDC vs MOIL is a comparison of three state-run miners that trade at Rs 393.10, Rs 68.01 and Rs 214.00 on NSE as of 3:08 PM IST on 19 November 2026.
This article puts the three side by side on business mix, size, September quarter results, valuation, dividend yield, ownership shifts and dated broker views. Ratios marked as our arithmetic are recomputed at the live price, and the comparison does not name a winner.
Click Here – Get Free Investment Predictions
Business Mix: Coal, Iron Ore and Manganese
| Company | Main product | Status and scale |
|---|---|---|
| Coal India | Thermal and coking coal | Maharatna PSU; world’s largest coal producer with over 80% of the domestic market; FY27 production target of 815 million tonnes |
| NMDC | Iron ore, plus pellets and diamonds | Navratna PSU; capacity of about 51 million tonnes a year of about 64% Fe ore |
| MOIL | Manganese ore and electrolytic manganese dioxide | Miniratna PSU; India’s largest manganese ore producer with about 53% share and the only maker of electrolytic manganese dioxide |
Each company sells a different commodity into a different end market. Coal India depends on power demand and e-auction premiums, NMDC on steel demand and iron ore prices, and MOIL on steel and battery-grade manganese demand. That is why any direct ranking on one number is shaky. Scenario thinking is more useful than prediction when reading about this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and see how the picture looks at the end of the week. Small position sizes keep mistakes affordable when acting on the three state-run miners, because markets reprice quickly on new information.
For the sector context, the Nifty Metal index covers metal and mining shares, and the Nifty 50 is the wider benchmark. Univest has also published a piece on mining PSU stocks with long-term potential. A short list of questions helps when thinking about the three mining PSUs, and remember that targets and levels are not guarantees. Revisit your assumptions after each new filing when tracking Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, and keep notes so the reasoning can be reviewed later.
Live Prices and Size
| Measure | Coal India | NMDC | MOIL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price at 3:08 PM IST | Rs 393.10 | Rs 68.01 | Rs 214.00 |
| Change today | +1.31% | -0.34% | +1.33% |
| Market value at live price (our arithmetic) | About Rs 2.43 lakh crore | About Rs 59,900 crore | About Rs 4,355 crore |
| Promoter holding, September 2026 | 61.13% | 60.79% | 64.68% |
Coal India is about 40 times the size of NMDC and about 56 times the size of MOIL by market value (our arithmetic), so MOIL is a small-cap and trades with thinner liquidity than the other two. The government is the promoter of all three. Official disclosures should anchor any discussion about this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and return to the filing if something looks odd. A short list of questions helps when thinking about the three state-run miners, because markets reprice quickly on new information.
September Quarter Results Compared
| Rs crore | Coal India Sep 2025 | Coal India Sep 2026 | NMDC Sep 2025 | NMDC Sep 2026 | MOIL Sep 2025 | MOIL Sep 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 38,693.53 | 46,832.73 | 6,761.43 | 7,132.15 | 363.02 | 385.02 |
| Net profit | 4,167.18 | 6,547.43 | 1,682.65 | 1,664.39 | 70.44 | 61.77 |
| Operating margin | 24.47% | 25.91% | 37.26% | 36.66% | 39.00% | 34.00% |
Coal India’s revenue rose 21.0% and net profit 57.1% on the year, though profit was 26.0% lower than the June quarter’s Rs 8,849.81 crore (our arithmetic). NMDC’s revenue rose 5.5% while profit slipped 1.1%, and its margin stayed above 36%. Liquidity and bid-ask spreads deserve a look when reading the three state-run miners, and weigh it against your own time horizon. Official disclosures should anchor any discussion about this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and let the next disclosure confirm or challenge the view.
MOIL’s revenue rose 6.1% but profit fell 12.3% and the margin dropped five points to 34.00%. NMDC and Coal India held margins better, and MOIL had the weakest profit trend of the three in this quarter. Keep a written note of the price level you are using while tracking the three mining PSUs, and do not assume that a past pattern will repeat.
Coal India vs NMDC vs MOIL on Valuation and Dividend Yield
| Measure | Coal India | NMDC | MOIL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trailing earnings per share | Rs 54.31 | Rs 8.45 | Rs 14.49 |
| P/E at live price (our arithmetic) | 7.2 | 8.0 | 14.8 |
| Industry P/E | 8.23 | 8.23 | 14.28 |
| Book value per share | Rs 206.84 | Rs 41.88 | Rs 139.12 |
| Price to book at live price (our arithmetic) | 1.90 | 1.62 | 1.54 |
| Return on equity | 26.17% | 20.18% | 10.42% |
| Dividend yield | 6.82% | 5.12% | 2.52% |
| Debt to equity | 0.12 | 0.20 | 0.00 |
Coal India and NMDC trade just below their industry multiple of 8.23, while MOIL trades slightly above its own sector’s 14.28. Coal India offers the highest yield and return on equity, and MOIL the lowest debt, with none. Check the exchange filings before forming a view on this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and look for confirmation across several data points. Liquidity and bid-ask spreads deserve a look when reading the three state-run miners, because markets reprice quickly on new information.
A low P/E on a coal or iron ore company often reflects expected falls in commodity-linked earnings, so low-looking numbers carry a cycle risk. The yields are based on the previous close and past payouts and can change with future dividends. Treat any single headline as incomplete when reading this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, because markets reprice quickly on new information. Decide the amount at risk first, then form an opinion on the three state-run miners, and look for confirmation across several data points.
Compare PSU and mining stocks with the Univest Screener
Ownership Shifts in the September Quarter
| Holder, Jun to Sep 2026 | Coal India | NMDC | MOIL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foreign institutions | 10.37% to 9.59% | 13.59% to 14.91% | 3.73% to 1.52% |
| Domestic institutions | 22.20% to 23.45% | 13.81% to 12.51% | 6.82% to 6.61% |
| Public | 6.29% to 5.83% | 11.80% to 11.78% | 24.76% to 27.18% |
Foreign institutions trimmed Coal India by 0.78 points and MOIL by 2.21, and added 1.32 to NMDC (our arithmetic). Domestic institutions did the opposite at Coal India, adding 1.25 points, and cut NMDC by 1.30. Reading the fine print is a good habit before settling on a view of the three mining PSUs, because headlines compress a lot of detail. Revisit your assumptions after each new filing when tracking Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, before any money is committed.
At MOIL the public holding rose 2.42 points as foreign institutions left, which fits the picture of a stock moving from institutions to retail hands. Coal India’s promoter stake also stood at 63.13% in March against 61.13% since June. Avoid acting on rumours when you are reading about the three state-run miners, and look for confirmation across several data points. Market direction on the day also colours any view on this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and check whether the news was already in the price.
What Brokerages Have Said
| Company | Broker view | Date | Upside at live price (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|
| NMDC | Motilal Oswal, Buy, target Rs 85; earnings in line, healthy iron ore prices offset weak seasonal volumes | 12 November 2026 | 25.0% |
| Coal India | Jefferies, Buy, target Rs 506, citing recovery in offtake | March 2026 | 28.7% |
| Metals sector | Emkay named NMDC and Coal India as its least preferred stocks; JPMorgan rated NMDC reduce with a target of Rs 78 | February 2026 | Not applicable |
Views are split and some predate the September results, so they are context and not a guide to today’s valuation. We did not find a recent published target for MOIL. Coal India’s volume rose 6.7% in April to August 2026 on a low base, per a brokerage note. A fair review looks at both the positives and the risks of Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, because markets reprice quickly on new information. Avoid acting on rumours when you are reading about the three mining PSUs, and see how the picture looks at the end of the week.
The headline behind this comparison asks which stock has a strong outlook, and no single source we found answers that for all three. A fair reading is that each has different drivers and different risks. Decide the amount at risk first, then form an opinion on this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, because one session rarely tells the full story.
Risks Specific to Each Company
Coal India’s profit fell 26.0% from the June quarter, and its earnings depend on offtake volumes and e-auction premiums. NMDC relies on iron ore prices and faces seasonal volume swings. MOIL has the smallest base, the weakest profit trend in the latest quarter and the thinnest institutional support. Avoid acting on rumours when you are reading about Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, because headlines compress a lot of detail. Verify the time stamp on every quote you use while reading the three mining PSUs, because liquidity can thin out near the close.
All three are government-controlled, so policy decisions on dividends, pricing and stake sales matter. A high yield is only as dependable as the payout decision behind it. Experienced investors usually wait for confirmation before acting on the three state-run miners, which keeps the discussion grounded in data.
How to Use This Comparison and What to Track Next
Choose the measure that matches your own goal. Income-focused readers may look at yield and debt, while those following earnings momentum may look at the quarterly profit trend. No single number settles it. Verify the time stamp on every quote you use while reading the three mining PSUs, and remember that targets and levels are not guarantees. Check the exchange filings before forming a view on Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, and avoid chasing a move that has already happened.
Track the December quarter results, monthly coal production data, iron ore prices and the next holding data. Watching whether foreign institutions return to MOIL would also be informative. Past patterns give context, not certainty, when reading about the three mining PSUs, especially around results and corporate announcements. A diversified portfolio limits the damage from being wrong on Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, especially if the quote is more than a few minutes old.
Univest does not give buy or sell calls, and this article is general information. Size any position to your own risk limits. Verify the time stamp on every quote you use while reading Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, and scale any position to the risk you can absorb. Rounded numbers in headlines can hide detail when reading the three mining PSUs, and note that figures can be revised later.
Download the Univest iOS App or Univest Android App to set price alerts on Coal India, NMDC and MOIL.
Conclusion
Coal India has the lowest P/E at about 7.2 and the highest yield at 6.82%, NMDC trades at about 8.0 times with a 5.12% yield, and MOIL at about 14.8 times with a 2.52% yield. The three sell different commodities, so the comparison shows trade-offs and not a ranking. Official disclosures should anchor any discussion about the three state-run miners, and ask what would change your mind. Reading the fine print is a good habit before settling on a view of this coal, iron ore and manganese trio, and ask what would change your mind.
Coal India’s profit rose 57.1% on the year, NMDC’s slipped 1.1% and MOIL’s fell 12.3%. Dated broker views are split, and the December quarter, commodity prices and ownership data are the next checkpoints. Official disclosures should anchor any discussion about Coal India, NMDC and MOIL side by side, and weigh it against your own time horizon. Check the exchange filings before forming a view on the three mining PSUs, because markets reprice quickly on new information.
Disclaimer: Data and figures in this article are sourced from publicly available information. These may or may not be accurate. Please verify all data with the official NSE (nseindia.com) and BSE (bseindia.com) websites before making any investment decision. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice by Univest (SEBI RA INH000013776).
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of Coal India, NMDC and MOIL has the highest dividend yield?
Ans. Coal India has the highest trailing dividend yield at 6.82%, followed by NMDC at 5.12% and MOIL at 2.52%, based on the previous close. Yields change with the price and with future payout decisions, so check the latest declared dividends before relying on them.
Which of the three has the lowest P/E ratio?
Ans. Coal India has the lowest, at about 7.2 times trailing earnings at the live price of Rs 393.10 (our arithmetic), against about 8.0 for NMDC and 14.8 for MOIL. Coal India and NMDC trade just below their industry multiple of 8.23, while MOIL is slightly above its sector’s 14.28.
How did the three companies perform in the September 2026 quarter?
Ans. Coal India’s profit rose 57.1% on the year to Rs 6,547.43 crore, NMDC’s fell 1.1% to Rs 1,664.39 crore, and MOIL’s fell 12.3% to Rs 61.77 crore. Revenue rose 21.0% at Coal India, 5.5% at NMDC and 6.1% at MOIL.
Which of the three has the strongest outlook?
Ans. Univest does not pick one. The companies sell coal, iron ore and manganese, each with different demand drivers, and the broker views we found are dated and split. Coal India has the highest return on equity at 26.17%, but its latest profit fell 26.0% from the June quarter.
Which stock carries the least debt?
Ans. MOIL has no debt, with a debt to equity ratio of 0.00, compared with 0.12 for Coal India and 0.20 for NMDC. Low debt reduces financial risk, but MOIL also has the lowest return on equity of the three at 10.42%, and its profit fell 12.3% in the latest quarter.
What are brokerages saying about these stocks?
Ans. Motilal Oswal kept a Buy on NMDC with a target of Rs 85 on 12 November, and Jefferies had a Buy on Coal India with a Rs 506 target in March. Emkay and JPMorgan were cautious on NMDC in February. These are dated third-party views, and we did not find a recent target for MOIL.
Should I buy Coal India, NMDC or MOIL after this comparison?
Ans. Univest does not give buy or sell calls. The comparison shows trade-offs between yield, valuation, margins and size, and each company faces commodity and policy risks. Compare more than one source, read the filings and size any position to your own risk limits.