Broken Wing Butterfly Explained: How the Uneven Wings Work, Payoff, Break-Even, Where Maximum Profit and Loss Sit and When Traders Use It
- November 19, 2026
- Posted by: Ankit Jaiswal
- Category: Market
Broken wing butterfly = a butterfly with one wing wider than the other, often for a net credit. Profit peaks at the middle strike. Risk is on the wide wing side. The narrow side can have no loss.
Quick Answer
Broken wing butterfly explained simply: it is a butterfly spread with unequal wings, where you buy one option, sell two at the middle strike and buy another option further away on one side, often for a net credit. Maximum profit sits at the middle strike, and the maximum loss sits only on the wide wing side. If the credit covers the narrow wing’s width, the other side has no loss, which makes the setup more flexible than a regular butterfly.
Broken wing butterfly explained for options traders who know the regular butterfly and want a version with a better risk profile on one side: the uneven wings change where the risk sits.
This guide covers the legs, an example, break-evens and when to use it. It is educational and not a recommendation.
Click Here – Get Free Investment Predictions
Broken Wing Butterfly Explained: The Structure
A regular call butterfly buys one lower strike, sells two middle strikes and buys one higher strike, with equal distances between them. In a broken wing butterfly, one wing is longer. You skip a strike on one side, so the distance to the far strike is bigger.
| Leg | Action | Example (call version) |
|---|---|---|
| Lower strike | Buy 1 call | 24,000 |
| Middle strike | Sell 2 calls | 24,200 |
| Upper strike (skipped one) | Buy 1 call | 24,600 (wide wing) |
Here the narrow wing is 200 points (24,000 to 24,200) and the wide wing is 400 points (24,200 to 24,600). Because the far option costs less, the position is often opened for a small net credit.
Worked Example
| Item | Value (illustrative) |
|---|---|
| Net credit | 30 points |
| Narrow wing width | 200 points |
| Wide wing width | 400 points |
| Maximum profit | At 24,200: 200 + 30 = 230 points |
| Maximum loss | Above 24,600: 400 – 200 – 30 = 170 points |
| Loss below 24,000 | Limited to the 30 point credit, so no loss |
With a lot size of 75 for illustration, 230 points is Rs 17,250 and 170 points is Rs 12,750. Check current lot sizes and premiums before trading.
How the Payoff Looks
- Below the lower strike, all options expire worthless and you keep the credit.
- Between the lower and middle strike, profit rises towards the peak.
- At the middle strike, profit is at the maximum.
- Between the middle and upper strike, profit falls and turns to a loss.
- Above the upper strike, the loss stays at the maximum, since the wide wing has capped it.
In the call version, the lower strike holds a long call and the middle strike holds two short call positions, while the upper strike holds another long call. A broken wing butterfly has a break-even point on the risk side, and another near the lower strike if there is a debit. Check each break-even level before placing the order, and remember that a broken wing butterfly changes shape as expiry nears. Pick the strike price of the middle leg first, then place the wings.
Use the Univest Screener to check live fundamentals before you act on any idea.
Why Use a Broken Wing Butterfly
The regular butterfly has a limited profit zone and a loss on both sides. The broken wing version removes the loss on one side, or reduces it, in exchange for a bigger loss on the other. If you expect the market to drift slowly towards a target and are comfortable that a big move in the other direction is unlikely, the structure fits.
| Feature | Regular butterfly | Broken wing butterfly |
|---|---|---|
| Wings | Equal | Unequal |
| Entry | Usually a debit | Often a small credit |
| Risk | Limited on both sides | Limited, but larger on the wide side |
| Best for | Pin at a level | Drift towards a level with an edge on one side |
Compare a broken wing butterfly with a regular butterfly before trading. The broken wing butterfly often brings a credit, while the regular version gives a narrower profit zone. A trader who picks a broken wing butterfly accepts a bigger loss on one side in return.
Risks and Margin
- The wide wing side can lose more than a regular butterfly.
- Four legs mean costs add up.
- Margin is needed for the net short position and depends on exchange rules.
- Time decay helps near the middle strike but can hurt if the market is far from it.
- Liquidity matters. Choose strikes with tight spreads.
Index options on the Nifty 50 are the common choice. Place the middle strike where you think the index will settle, and always size the maximum loss to fit your limit.
Managing the Trade
- Choose the middle strike from support, resistance and expected range.
- Check that the net credit covers the narrow wing width if you want no loss on that side.
- Set a loss rule on the wide wing side.
- Take profit before expiry, since the peak profit is narrow.
- Avoid holding through major events.
Download the Univest iOS App or Univest Android App to get daily stock research and market updates.
Conclusion
A broken wing butterfly uses uneven wings to shift risk to one side and often brings a net credit. Maximum profit sits at the middle strike and maximum loss on the wide wing side.
It suits a view that the market will drift to a level, not break far past it.
Disclaimer: Data and figures in this article are sourced from publicly available information. These may or may not be accurate. Please verify all data with the official NSE (nseindia.com) and BSE (bseindia.com) websites before making any investment decision. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice by Univest (SEBI RA INH000013776).
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a broken wing butterfly?
Ans. It is a butterfly options spread with unequal wings. You buy one option, sell two at the middle strike and buy one more option further out on one side, skipping a strike. It is often opened for a small net credit.
How is it different from a regular butterfly?
Ans. A regular butterfly has equal wings and usually costs a debit. A broken wing butterfly has one longer wing, which often brings a credit and removes the loss on one side, while the other side can lose more.
What is the maximum profit?
Ans. The maximum profit is at the middle strike at expiry. It equals the width of the narrow wing plus the net credit, or minus the net debit. Profit falls as the underlying moves away from the middle strike.
What is the maximum loss?
Ans. It occurs beyond the far strike of the wide wing and equals the wide wing width minus the narrow wing width minus the net credit. On the narrow wing side, the loss is limited to the debit or nil if the position was opened for a credit.
When should I use it?
Ans. When you expect the underlying to drift towards a level and you want a credit with a risk profile that favours one side. Avoid it before major events that can cause a large move.
Is it suitable for beginners?
Ans. It has defined risk, but four legs and uneven wings need careful study. Learn the regular butterfly first and paper trade the broken wing version before using real money.
How much margin does it need?
Ans. Less than a naked position because the long options hedge the short ones, but the amount depends on exchange rules. Use the broker margin calculator before placing the trade.