Univest
Univest
  • Markets

Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors After Q2: TMPV Falls 8.7% to Rs 262 on a Rs 5,451 Crore Loss and JLR Guidance Cut While Eicher Posts Record Revenue and a 15% Profit Rise

  • November 16, 2026
  • Posted by: Harsh Piplani
  • Category: News
No Comments
Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors After Q2: TMPV Falls 8.7% to Rs 262 on a Rs 5,451 Crore Loss and JLR Guidance Cut While Eicher Posts Record Revenue and a 15% Profit Rise

TMPV Rs 262.40 (-8.70%), Eicher Rs 7,599 (-0.67%) at 3:45 PM, 16 Nov. TMPV Q2 loss Rs 5,451 cr. Eicher revenue Rs 7,422 cr (+20%), profit Rs 1,573 cr (+15%).

Quick Answer

The two auto stocks reacted to very different quarters. Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles posted record revenue of Rs 96,920 crore but a loss of Rs 5,451 crore after Rs 6,738 crore of one-time charges, and Jaguar Land Rover cut its FY27 margin guidance, so the stock fell 8.7%. Eicher Motors reported record revenue of Rs 7,422 crore and a 15% rise in profit to Rs 1,573 crore. Eicher is far more expensive on earnings, while TMPV trades near book value. Univest does not give buy or sell calls.

Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors after Q2 is a choice between a turnaround story with high uncertainty and a steady compounder priced for quality. TMPV traded near Rs 262.40, down 8.7%, and Eicher near Rs 7,599, down 0.67%, at 3:45 PM on 16 November 2026.

This guide compares the quarterly results, valuation measures, business drivers and chart levels, and lists the risks on each side. It does not pick a winner, because the answer depends on how much volatility an investor can accept and for how long.

Click Here – Get Free Investment Predictions

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • The Q2 FY27 Scorecard
  • What Is Behind Each Result
  • Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors: Valuation Side by Side
  • Chart Levels After the Results
  • Risks and Questions to Watch
  • Conclusion
  • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Which is a better stock after Q2, Tata Motors PV or Eicher Motors?
    • Why did Tata Motors PV shares fall 8.7% on 16 November 2026?
    • What were Eicher Motors Q2 FY27 results?
    • Is Tata Motors PV profitable?
    • How do the valuations of TMPV and Eicher compare?
    • What are the share prices of TMPV and Eicher today?
    • What are the main risks for each stock?

The Q2 FY27 Scorecard

Metric Tata Motors PV (NSE) Eicher Motors (NSE)
Price, 3:45 PM Rs 262.40, down 8.70% Rs 7,599, down 0.67%
Revenue Rs 96,920 crore, up 34% Rs 7,422 crore, up 20%
Net result Loss of Rs 5,451 crore (continuing) Profit of Rs 1,573 crore, up 15%
Operating profit Pre-exceptional PBT Rs 403 crore PBIDT Rs 2,277 crore, up 14%
Volumes India PV above 2 lakh units, up about 40% Royal Enfield 3,76,722 units, up 15%

TMPV’s loss comes from about Rs 6,738 crore of exceptional items, including Rs 3,776 crore for employee separation and Rs 2,856 crore for impairment. One report puts the loss attributable to shareholders at Rs 5,531 crore, so check the filing for the exact figure. Updates related to Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock often arrive after market hours, so check again at the next open. Note the date and time of any price quoted in TMPV vs Eicher Motors.

What Is Behind Each Result

Driver Tata Motors PV Eicher Motors
Core business India PV revenue Rs 20,423 crore, up 50.9%, EBITDA margin 4.0% Royal Enfield domestic sales 3,40,847 units
Overseas or JV JLR revenue 5.9 billion pounds, adjusted EBIT margin 1.1% VE Commercial Vehicles adds to profit, margin 8.4% in Q1
Guidance JLR FY27 EBIT margin cut to 2% to 3%, free cash outflow about 1.25 billion pounds Capacity expansion under way after record volumes
Balance sheet Net debt about Rs 50,800 crore Debt to equity about 0.02

TMPV said EV sales grew about 90% and that it had passed on about 40% of the commodity cost increase so far. Eicher’s quarter was driven by volume, and the company has said it will ramp up production to meet demand. No single data point settles the question on TMPV vs Eicher Motors. A calm review of TMPV and Eicher shares usually beats a rushed reaction to one headline.

Compare auto stocks on the Univest Screener

Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors: Valuation Side by Side

Measure TMPV Eicher
Price to earnings Not meaningful, loss-making over 12 months About 36.5
Industry price to earnings About 26.2 About 26.2
Price to book About 1.01 About 8.39
Return on equity About 4.5% About 23%
Dividend yield About 1.05% About 1.07%

The valuation gap tells the story. Eicher earns a high return on equity with almost no debt and trades at a premium to the industry, while TMPV trades close to book value because the market doubts how quickly JLR earnings recover. On TMPV and Eicher shares, a fair view compares today’s numbers with the previous quarter. Many investors revisit Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock after the closing bell once final volumes are known.

To compare automobile stocks side by side, use the Univest Screener. Volume is a useful cross-check for TMPV and Eicher shares. Broader market direction also influences Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock on any given day.

Chart Levels After the Results

Reference TMPV Eicher
Previous close Rs 287.40 Rs 7,650
Day high and low Rs 272.95 and Rs 260.35 Rs 7,947 and Rs 7,534
50-day average About Rs 287.48 About Rs 7,355.52
RSI (14-day) About 51 About 70

TMPV now trades below its 50-day average after a gap down, while Eicher is above it with momentum already near overbought territory. TMPV was also among the weaker large stocks on the Nifty 50 on 13 November, before the results. Eicher spiked toward Rs 7,947 early on 16 November and gave back much of the gain. These are reference levels, not predictions. With TMPV vs Eicher Motors, position size matters more than precision. The next filing or data release could change how TMPV and Eicher shares is read.

Risks and Questions to Watch

Stock Main questions
TMPV JLR margin and cash flow against the cut guidance, commodity pass-through, EV supply that covers only 60% to 65% of demand
Eicher Valuation after the run, commodity costs, VE Commercial Vehicles margins, demand after a high base

Univest does not give buy or sell calls, and this article is general information. Match the stock to your own risk limits and time horizon. Past patterns behind Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock do not guarantee a repeat. Reading TMPV vs Eicher Motors alongside the sector trend avoids a narrow conclusion.

Download the Univest iOS App or Univest Android App to track auto stocks and set price alerts.

Conclusion

TMPV offers a record India business and a price near book value, set against a loss, a guidance cut and JLR uncertainty. Eicher offers record volumes, high returns and a premium price. For TMPV vs Eicher Motors, confirm each figure against the exchange filing before relying on it. Set risk limits before acting on any view of TMPV and Eicher shares. For Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock, confirm each figure against the exchange filing before relying on it.

Neither is a simple choice. Watch JLR’s cash flow and margins for TMPV and valuation and commodity costs for Eicher. When reading Tata Motors PV vs Eicher stock, intraday moves can reverse before the close, so timing matters. Comparing TMPV vs Eicher Motors with peers gives a better sense of context. When reading TMPV and Eicher shares, intraday moves can reverse before the close, so timing matters.

Disclaimer: Data and figures in this article are sourced from publicly available information. These may or may not be accurate. Please verify all data with the official NSE (nseindia.com) and BSE (bseindia.com) websites before making any investment decision. Investments in securities are subject to market risk. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice by Univest (SEBI RA INH000013776).

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is a better stock after Q2, Tata Motors PV or Eicher Motors?

Ans. Univest does not give buy or sell calls. Eicher had the cleaner quarter with record revenue and a 15% profit rise, while TMPV carries a loss and a guidance cut but trades near book value. The answer depends on your risk limits.

Why did Tata Motors PV shares fall 8.7% on 16 November 2026?

Ans. The stock fell after Q2 results showed a Rs 5,451 crore loss from Rs 6,738 crore of exceptional charges and Jaguar Land Rover cut its FY27 EBIT margin guidance to 2% to 3% with a free cash outflow of about 1.25 billion pounds.

What were Eicher Motors Q2 FY27 results?

Ans. Eicher reported record revenue of Rs 7,422 crore, up 20%, consolidated net profit of Rs 1,573 crore, up 15%, and PBIDT of Rs 2,277 crore, up 14%, with Royal Enfield selling a record 3,76,722 motorcycles.

Is Tata Motors PV profitable?

Ans. Not on a reported basis this quarter. It made a Rs 403 crore profit before tax and exceptional items but a Rs 5,451 crore loss after one-time charges, and its trailing 12-month earnings per share is negative.

How do the valuations of TMPV and Eicher compare?

Ans. Eicher trades at about 36.5 times earnings and 8.4 times book with a return on equity near 23%, while TMPV trades at about 1.0 times book with a return on equity near 4.5% and no meaningful price to earnings.

What are the share prices of TMPV and Eicher today?

Ans. At about 3:45 PM IST on 16 November 2026, TMPV traded near Rs 262.40, down 8.70%, and Eicher near Rs 7,599, down 0.67%. Prices change quickly, so check live quotes before any decision. TMPV had closed at Rs 287.40 and Eicher at Rs 7,650 on the previous session.

What are the main risks for each stock?

Ans. For TMPV, the main risks are JLR margins and cash flow after the guidance cut and commodity costs. For Eicher, they are the high valuation, commodity costs and the sustainability of record volumes after a high base.



Auto Stocks After Q2 eicher motors share price JLR Guidance Royal Enfield Sales Tata Motors PV vs Eicher Motors After Q2 tmpv share price
Author: Harsh Piplani
I am Harsh Piplani, an Assistant Content Manager with over 5 years of experience in crafting impactful, result-driven content. I hold a B.Com (Hons) degree and have worked across diverse industries, including education, fintech, healthcare, jewellery, and more. I specialise in content strategy, SEO, and optimisation, ensuring that every piece I create is not just well-written but also well-ranked. I believe content should do more than fill space so as to drive traffic, build authority, and support business growth. I enjoy turning complex ideas into clear, engaging narratives, and, as I like to say, I know how to spin words like a web to influence, structured, strategic, and impossible to ignore. For me, great content sits at the intersection of creativity and performance.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply